An SEO competitor analysis shows you why other websites outrank you and what it would take to close the gap. Instead of guessing which keywords to target or which pages to improve, you study the sites that already win the searches you care about: their keywords, their best pages, their links and their technical setup. Done well, it turns into a short, prioritized list of actions rather than a large spreadsheet nobody uses.
This guide walks through the process step by step, explains what to record at each stage and includes a simple template you can copy into Google Sheets or Excel. It works for B2B service firms, SaaS companies and online stores, and you can do a useful first version with free tools.
What an SEO competitor analysis covers
Your SEO competitors are not always your business competitors. A software company may compete in search with review sites, publishers and agencies' blogs that would never bid for the same contract. For SEO, a competitor is any site that ranks for the searches your buyers use.
A complete analysis looks at five areas:
| Area | Question it answers | Typical sources |
|---|---|---|
| Competitor set | Who actually ranks for our priority searches? | Manual Google searches, SEO tools' "organic competitors" reports |
| Keywords | What do they rank for that we do not, or rank better for? | Keyword gap tools, Google Search Console for your own site |
| Content | Why do their pages satisfy searchers better than ours? | Reading the ranking pages, the search results page itself |
| Links and mentions | Who links to them and why? | Backlink tools, searches for brand mentions |
| Technical and UX | Is their site faster, better structured or easier to crawl? | PageSpeed Insights, Rich Results Test, a crawl of their public pages |
You do not need to cover every area in depth every time. If your problem is that a handful of service pages are stuck on page two, focus on content and links for those pages. If you are planning a new blog, focus on keywords and content gaps.
Step 1: Define the searches that matter
Start with your own priorities, not with competitors. List 10 to 30 searches that would bring you qualified buyers: core service or product terms, the problems buyers search for and the comparison searches they run before deciding. If you have not done this yet, our guide on how to do keyword research for SEO covers it in detail.
Group the searches by topic, for example "technical SEO audit", "link building" and "website redesign". You will compare competitors topic by topic, because a site can be strong in one area and weak in another.
Check your own starting point in Google Search Console. The Performance report shows the queries and pages you already get impressions for and your average position, which tells you where you are close to page one and where you are absent.
Step 2: Identify your real search competitors
Search each priority keyword in a private browser window, with the location set to the market you serve, and record every domain in the top ten results. After a few dozen searches, some domains will appear again and again. Those are your main SEO competitors.
Sort them into three groups:
- Direct competitors. Businesses that sell what you sell and rank for your terms.
- Content competitors. Publishers, blogs, review sites and directories that rank for your topics but do not sell the same service.
- Aspirational competitors. Larger brands that dominate the results and are useful to learn from, but are not realistic short-term targets.
Pick three to five domains to analyze, weighted toward direct competitors and the content competitors that appear most often. If you use an SEO tool, its "organic competitors" or "competing domains" report is a quick cross-check, but always confirm with real searches, because tool databases do not cover every query.
Note anything else on the results page: AI Overviews, People also ask boxes, videos, local map results or shopping results. These features change how many clicks the ordinary blue links receive, and they tell you what format Google thinks searchers want.
Step 3: Run a keyword gap analysis
A keyword gap analysis compares the keywords your site ranks for with the keywords your competitors rank for. Most SEO platforms have a gap or comparison tool for this. Enter your domain and up to four competitors, then look at two lists:
- Missing keywords: searches where competitors rank and you do not appear at all.
- Weak keywords: searches where you rank, but well below one or more competitors.
Filter both lists hard. Remove keywords that are irrelevant to what you sell, branded searches for the competitor's own name and anything that would attract the wrong audience. Then sort what remains by relevance to your services and by realistic difficulty, not only by search volume. A specific long-tail search used by the right buyers is usually worth more than a broad term you have little chance of ranking for.
Without a paid tool, you can still run a lighter version: take your priority topics, search the main variations and note where each competitor appears and where you do not. Google autocomplete and the People also ask box are good sources of related questions to check.
Step 4: Study the pages that outrank you
Keyword data tells you where the gaps are. The ranking pages tell you why they exist. For each priority keyword, open the top three to five results and compare them with your page, if you have one.
Look at:
- Search intent and format. Are the top results guides, checklists, comparison pages, tools or service pages? If every result is a step-by-step guide and your page is a sales page, intent is the problem, not wording.
- Coverage. Which subtopics, questions and steps do they include that you do not? Which do they all miss?
- Evidence and expertise. Do they show who wrote the page, cite sources, include original examples, screenshots or data?
- Freshness. When were they last updated, and does that matter for the topic?
- Structure. Clear headings, tables, summaries and FAQs make pages easier to scan and easier for search engines and AI search tools to quote.
- Calls to action. How do they move a reader to the next step, and does it fit the intent?
Google's guidance on creating helpful, reliable, people-first content is a good lens here. It asks whether content provides original information, analysis or research and offers substantial value compared with other pages in search results. The aim is to find what the ranking pages do well and where you can genuinely do better, not to produce a longer copy of the same thing.
If your existing page already covers the topic but has slipped, a refresh is often faster than a new page. Our content refresh strategy guide explains how to decide.
Step 5: Compare backlinks and brand mentions
Links from relevant, trusted sites remain one of the clearest differences between pages that rank and pages that do not. Use a backlink tool to compare the number of referring domains, not just total links, for each competitor and for the specific pages that outrank you.
Then run a link gap analysis: list sites that link to two or more competitors but not to you. These sites have already shown they link to your topic. Review them by relevance and quality, and look at why they linked:
- Industry directories, associations and partner pages you could also qualify for
- Articles and roundups that cite a competitor's guide, research or tool
- Guest articles, interviews and podcast appearances
- News coverage from digital PR campaigns
Ignore links you could only match by buying them or joining link schemes; Google's spam policies treat those as link spam. Our guide on how to build backlinks for SEO covers the legitimate tactics in more depth.
Step 6: Check technical SEO and page experience
Technical issues rarely explain the whole gap, but they can hold back strong content. For your key pages and the competitor pages that outrank them, compare:
- Speed and Core Web Vitals. PageSpeed Insights shows field data from real Chrome users, when enough is available, for any public URL, so you can compare your pages with theirs.
- Structured data. The Rich Results Test shows which rich-result types a public page is eligible for, such as FAQ, product, review or breadcrumb markup.
- Site structure and internal links. How many clicks from the homepage are their key pages, and how well do their articles link to related service pages?
- Mobile experience. Read their pages on a phone. Intrusive pop-ups, tiny text and slow menus all affect how people experience the page.
- Indexing basics. Clean URLs, sensible titles and meta descriptions, and canonical tags that match the page.
For a deeper review of your own site, follow our technical SEO audit checklist.
Step 7: Check AI search and other visibility
Search is no longer just ten blue links. For your priority questions, check which brands and pages are cited in Google AI Overviews and AI Mode, ChatGPT search, Perplexity and Microsoft Copilot. Answers vary by person and over time, so record the pattern across several checks rather than one result.
If competitors are cited and you are not, compare the cited pages in the same way as in Step 4: clear answers, named sources, up-to-date facts and mentions on other reputable sites. Our guide on how to optimize content for AI Overviews and ChatGPT explains what helps and which tactics to skip.
If you serve local customers, also compare Google Business Profiles: categories, reviews, photos and how complete each profile is.
Step 8: Turn findings into a prioritized plan
A competitor analysis is only useful if it changes what you do next. Go through your findings and turn each gap into a specific action with an owner and a target page. Then score each action on three questions:
- Impact: how relevant is the search to buyers, and how close are you already?
- Effort: is this a quick on-page fix, a new page, or months of link building?
- Confidence: is the gap clear and consistent across competitors, or a one-off?
Quick wins usually come first: pages ranking on page two that need better coverage, clearer titles or more internal links, which our on-page SEO checklist covers. New content and link building follow, because they take longer to show results.
SEO competitor analysis template
Copy this structure into a spreadsheet, with one tab per section. Keep the columns simple so the file stays useful after the first review.
Tab 1: Competitor overview
| Column | What to record |
|---|---|
| Domain | Competitor website |
| Type | Direct, content or aspirational |
| Priority topics where they rank | Topic groups from Step 1 |
| Strongest pages | URLs that rank for several of your priority searches |
| Referring domains | From your backlink tool (estimate) |
| Notable strengths | Content, links, brand, speed, reviews |
| Notable weaknesses | Outdated pages, thin coverage, poor mobile experience |
Tab 2: Keyword gap
| Keyword | Topic | Intent | Your position | Best competitor and position | Ranking page type | Action | Priority |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| example: technical seo audit checklist | Technical SEO | Informational | Not ranking | Competitor A, top 3 | Step-by-step guide | Create checklist guide | High |
Tab 3: Page comparison
| Keyword | Your URL | Competitor URL | Intent match | Topics they cover that you miss | Evidence and sources | Last updated | Action |
|---|
Tab 4: Link gap
| Linking site | Links to which competitors | Type of link | Relevance | Realistic approach | Status |
|---|
Tab 5: Technical and SERP features
| URL | Core Web Vitals (field data) | Structured data found | Mobile issues | SERP features present | AI search citations |
|---|
Tab 6: Action plan
| Action | Target page | Impact | Effort | Confidence | Owner | Due date | Result |
|---|
Add a short change log at the end so you can see which actions were completed and what moved when you repeat the analysis.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Analyzing business rivals instead of search competitors. The companies you meet in sales calls may not be the sites you compete with in Google.
- Chasing every gap. A keyword a competitor ranks for is only worth targeting if your buyers search it and you can create something better.
- Trusting tool estimates as facts. Traffic and keyword numbers for other sites are modeled estimates. Use them for comparison and direction, not as exact figures.
- Copying competitor content. Rewriting the top result rarely beats it. Add your own experience, examples and sources.
- Matching low-quality links. If a competitor ranks with paid or spammy links, copying that approach puts your site at risk.
- Making it a one-off report. Results change. Schedule a light monthly check and a full review once or twice a year.
How Sirajia Sol helps
Sirajia Sol works with B2B companies in the USA and worldwide, with delivery teams in our back offices in Lahore and Karachi. Our SEO team runs competitor and keyword gap analysis, reviews the pages that outrank you and turns the findings into a clear, prioritized plan. Our content and brand team helps you build pages that answer searchers better, and our digital PR team helps you earn the relevant links and mentions that close authority gaps.
If you want to know why competitors outrank you for the searches that matter most, contact us with your website and two or three competitors you keep seeing in search.
